The text is written for about a 7th grade reading level. That would be fine if the information provided were reliable. Unfortunately, that is not the case.
The photo at the beginning of chapter 25 caught my eye while first paging through, & the caption stated the photo was taken in India, so I began reading to learn more about it. The text only credited this one with crossing the Atlantic & says nothing about how it ended up in India. Worse, the same paragraph describes how "In 1933 and 1934, the seventh, eighth and ninth Atlantic crossings for Bellanca cabin planes were accomplished by Steve Darius and Stan Adamowicz in the White Falcon, and by Dr. Richard Light in a commercial seaplane, a Bellanca CH-300 Skyrocket, the Asulinak." There are so many mistakes in this sentence it's hard to count them all. Left entirely unclear is which flights crossed in which year, & that's the least of it.
There was a trans- Atlantic attempt in 1933 by brothers Benjamin & Joseph Adamowicz, ending with damage to their J-300 "White Eagle" in Newfoundland on the take-off attempt, but I know of no "Stan Adamowicz" & no "White Falcon". Ben & Joe made a successful crossing in 1934, the same plane now renamed "Warsaw". There was a Stephen Darius, but he flew another Bellanca across the Atlantic in 1933 with partner Stanley Girenus. That Bellanca was named "Lituanica" & it crashed fatally for both men in Northeastern Germany, not far short of their goal in Lithuania.
There is no index, but I see no photos & no mention of "Lituanica"... There is no such thing as a "CH-300 Skyrocket". You'd think somebody publishing a book about Bellancas could at least get THAT right! The photo shows a CH-400 Skyrocket. Given the problems with the stories I DO know there, I'm uncertain whether I've learned anything at all factual about Dr. Light's Skyrocket.
I love the photos, in spite of the middling reproduction quality, but the captions are as problematic as this bit of text. To whoever wrote these captions, all Bellancas must seem perfectly interchangeable. On pages 72 & 73 an earlier Bellanca CH or J & the later J-300 Special "Miss Veedol" are claimed to be the same aircraft. The other 2 photos on page 72 are also badly mis-captioned.
So if you already know what you're looking at regarding Bellancas, it's a fairly good picture book in spite of the indifferent image quality.
The text is written for about a 7th grade reading level. That would be fine if the information provided were reliable. Unfortunately, that is not the case.
The photo at the beginning of chapter 25 caught my eye while first paging through, & the caption stated the photo was taken in India, so I began reading to learn more about it. The text only credited this one with crossing the Atlantic & says nothing about how it ended up in India. Worse, the same paragraph describes how "In 1933 and 1934, the seventh, eighth and ninth Atlantic crossings for Bellanca cabin planes were accomplished by Steve Darius and Stan Adamowicz in the White Falcon, and by Dr. Richard Light in a commercial seaplane, a Bellanca CH-300 Skyrocket, the Asulinak." There are so many mistakes in this sentence it's hard to count them all. Left entirely unclear is which flights crossed in which year, & that's the least of it.
There was a trans- Atlantic attempt in 1933 by brothers Benjamin & Joseph Adamowicz, ending with damage to their J-300 "White Eagle" in Newfoundland on the take-off attempt, but I know of no "Stan Adamowicz" & no "White Falcon". Ben & Joe made a successful crossing in 1934, the same plane now renamed "Warsaw". There was a Stephen Darius, but he flew another Bellanca across the Atlantic in 1933 with partner Stanley Girenus. That Bellanca was named "Lituanica" & it crashed fatally for both men in Northeastern Germany, not far short of their goal in Lithuania.
There is no index, but I see no photos & no mention of "Lituanica"... There is no such thing as a "CH-300 Skyrocket". You'd think somebody publishing a book about Bellancas could at least get THAT right! The photo shows a CH-400 Skyrocket. Given the problems with the stories I DO know there, I'm uncertain whether I've learned anything at all factual about Dr. Light's Skyrocket.
I love the photos, in spite of the middling reproduction quality, but the captions are as problematic as this bit of text. To whoever wrote these captions, all Bellancas must seem perfectly interchangeable. On pages 72 & 73 an earlier Bellanca CH or J & the later J-300 Special "Miss Veedol" are claimed to be the same aircraft. The other 2 photos on page 72 are also badly mis-captioned.
So if you already know what you're looking at regarding Bellancas, it's a fairly good picture book in spite of the indifferent image quality.